The Athletic’s pick-by-pick grades for Round 1 of the 2024 NFL Draft provide evaluations of each selection made during the event. Factors considered include pick value, trade costs, and the overall board at the time of each pick. The breakdown offers insight into which teams made the right choices and which ones may come to regret their decisions in the future. The grades aim to provide a comprehensive assessment of each team’s draft performance, considering the potential impact of each selection.
The Bears made the rational decision to select quarterback Williams with the top pick, giving their franchise a much-needed Pro Bowl-caliber quarterback. Williams, known for his ability to make throws from any position and lead in tight situations, has the potential to elevate the Bears’ offense. With concerns about fumbling issues, Williams will need to work on certain areas of his game, but overall, the selection was deemed the right choice for Chicago.
Washington also addressed its quarterback needs by drafting Daniels, the 2023 Heisman Trophy winner. Known for his dual-threat abilities and improvement in college, Daniels brings a unique skill set to the team. Despite needing to work on his performance under pressure and throwing inside the numbers, Daniels’ potential and work ethic make him a strong pick for Washington.
The Patriots prioritized their need at quarterback by selecting Maye, a prototypical QB with tangible and intangible qualities that make him a valuable asset. While Maye’s development may require patience, his potential as a quarterback with upside makes him a worthy bet for New England. The Cardinals made a strong choice by adding Harrison, a top receiver prospect with no true weaknesses in his game, to complement quarterback Kyler Murray.
Michigan’s Harbaugh focused on fortifying the Chargers’ offensive line with Alt, an elite left tackle prospect with the physical attributes and skills to excel in the NFL. Alt’s pedigree and performance at Notre Dame make him a solid choice for Los Angeles. Meanwhile, the Giants opted for playmaker Nabers, a versatile and explosive receiver who adds speed to their offense, a sensible and potentially dynamic pick for New York.
Tennessee aimed to bolster its offensive line with Latham, a powerhouse tackle from Alabama. Despite questions about his potential switch to left tackle, Latham’s strength and consistency in run blocking make him a promising prospect for the Titans. The Falcons surprised by selecting Penix, a talented but unproven quarterback, raising concerns about his age, health, and effectiveness in pressure situations. Time will determine the success of this risky pick.
The Vikings made a strategic move by landing McCarthy, adding a talented quarterback to their roster without sacrificing additional draft picks. McCarthy’s aggressive style and winning track record make him a valuable asset for Minnesota. As teams continued to address their needs in the first round, the draft showcased a mix of calculated decisions, bold moves, and value picks that will shape the future of these franchises in the NFL.
